Painful Pleasures Reviews
Painful Pleasures has an overall rating of 3.3 based on 38 reviews. Customer feedback on Painful Pleasures is mixed: Painful Pleasures reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of products, competitive pricing, helpful customer service and fast shipping, which strongly appeal to body modification enthusiasts and tattoo professionals. However, Painful Pleasures is often criticized for its website navigation issues, occasional stock shortages, and slow response times for inquiries.
38 reviews
5 Stars
6
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
3
2 Stars
1
1 Star
5
How would you rate Painful Pleasures?
All Painful Pleasures Reviews (38)
william_Critchlow90
April 23, 2026
"Feels like the real deal"
I’ve ordered from Painful Pleasures a few times now, it’s always felt legit (which is obviously what you want when buying this kind of stuff). Everything I’ve received has matched the photos and descriptions, the packaging was normal, and nothing gave me that fake or sketchy vibe.
I also like that they carry brands I already recognize from actual shops, not just a bunch of random no-name products. Shipping was fine too (nothing crazy fast, but no issues), so overall it’s been a solid experience and I’d definitely order from them again.
I also like that they carry brands I already recognize from actual shops, not just a bunch of random no-name products. Shipping was fine too (nothing crazy fast, but no issues), so overall it’s been a solid experience and I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
steve_Gonzales00
April 22, 2026
"Sizing just didn’t work out for me"
I don’t remember the exact size I ordered off the top of my head, but I do remember checking the size chart before buying because I wanted to avoid this exact problem. When it arrived, it fit way smaller than I expected, to the point that I couldn’t really use it.
Maybe it works for some people, but for me the sizing felt really off. I mostly just remember being annoyed that I spent the money and still ended up with something that didn’t fit. I probably wouldn’t order again unless the sizing gets more accurate.
Maybe it works for some people, but for me the sizing felt really off. I mostly just remember being annoyed that I spent the money and still ended up with something that didn’t fit. I probably wouldn’t order again unless the sizing gets more accurate.
0
Reply
lillian1985
April 15, 2026
"Wholesale account works, but it makes me do extra checking"
I’ve been using painfulpleasures.com for a wholesale account, and it’s been hit or miss. Some of the prices are solid and they usually have a decent selection in stock, which is why I keep coming back. But the shipping updates can be slow, and I’ve had a couple items show up as backordered after I already paid, which is annoying. Customer service did get back to me, just not super quickly. It’s not a terrible experience, but it definitely feels like extra work on my end now because I have to double-check everything before I order.
0
Reply
william_Yuengling73
April 08, 2026
"Decent site, but umm, a little messy"
The site works okay overall, but umm, it feels a bit cluttered. I did find what I needed after clicking around for a while, though the filters and search could definitely be better. Checkout was fine, just not the smoothest on my phone...
0
Reply
William-mcwhorter
April 03, 2026
"Fast shipping, but wrong size item"
My order showed up quickly, which was nice, but one of the items was the wrong size from what I picked. Everything else was fine, so it wasn’t a total mess or anything, just annoying having to deal with it. What made it worse was getting one of those canned apology responses that feels like nobody actually read what happened. Not terrible overall, but definitely frustrating.
0
Reply
Joan_mills92
March 29, 2026
"Ended Up Browsing Longer Than Planned"
I went on Painful Pleasures just to grab a couple tattoo supplies and somehow ended up poking around way longer than I meant to. I kept clicking through different categories, half because I was curious and half because I kept seeing stuff I forgot existed or didn’t realize I might need. The site was easy to move around, and I liked that they had a bunch of different brands in one place. the best part is probably just how many options they have, so you don’t have to bounce between a bunch of other sites.
0
Reply
YvonneHedger
March 20, 2026
"I got to checkout and immediately thought..."
I got to checkout and immediately thought, okay, this might be a little much all at once. Then I saw the split payment option and was like, wait, perfect. It made the whole thing feel way less stressful and I could finish my order without overthinking it.
0
Reply
derek-Stallcup
March 16, 2026
"Pretty good quality overall"
I’d say the quality was good overall. It felt like it was about what I was expecting, maybe even a little better in some parts
0
Reply
JohnShrefler_53
March 12, 2026
"Stock info needs to be more accurate"
I really wish the site would show what’s actually in stock before I get all the way to checkout. It’s super frustrating to find out later that something isn’t really available, and it just feels like a waste of time. I don’t want to have to guess what I can actually buy.
0
Reply
MCCRACKEN
March 11, 2026
"Didn’t feel super professional"
I just didn’t feel that comfortable using this site. Something about the whole experiance felt a little off, and it didn’t seem as professional as I was expecting. I’d probably rather order from somewhere that feels more reliable and clear.
0
Reply
CaroleNichols_54
March 07, 2026
"Pretty accurate overall"
The product info matched what I received for the most part. There were a couple little things that felt slightly off, but nothing major.
0
Reply
hello_antonio930
February 22, 2026
"Clear aftercare tips that actually helped"
The aftercare info was really easy to follow, which I appreciated because I was already overthinking my new piercing on the bus ride home. I kept the little instruction sheet on my bathroom counter next to my toothpaste, and it made the whole healing process feel way less stressful. Everything healed up nicely, so no complaints from me.
0
Reply
charles2002
January 31, 2026
"Got it way faster than expected"
The shipping was super quick. I placed my order and, like, two days later it was already at my door. Happy with that
0
Reply
valarie-Lupez
January 26, 2026
"My delivery was late two times in…"
My delivery was late two times in a row, which was kinda annoying tbh. I get that delays happen, but twice is a bit much
0
Reply
amber.Floyd
January 18, 2026
"Refund Took a Bit Too Long"
The refund took a few days to come through, which was a little annoying. That said, support did get it sorted in the end, so I appreciate the help
0
Reply
loribryan6707
December 17, 2025
"The place felt really sterile and well-kept, which…"
The place felt really sterile and well-kept, which should be a given, but it still made a big difference. I felt safe the whole time and had no concerns.
0
Reply
rose-Janicki
December 13, 2025
"i mean, I ordered from painfulpleasures and…"
i mean, I ordered from painfulpleasures and the packaging was not great. The box showed up beat up, and there wasn’t really enough padding inside, so everything was just sliding around during shipping. A couple of the items had bent corners, and one of them even leaked a little. The products themselves might be fine, but the way it was packed made the whole order feel kind of careless. Definitely not what I expected.
0
Reply
VickieSlevin
December 12, 2025
"Updates Were There, But Not Always Clear"
They did keep me updated, which I appreciated, but the communication could’ve been a lot clearer. Sometimes I’d get an update and still not really know what was going on or what to expect next, which was annoying.
0
Reply
CheriJackson_89
December 08, 2025
"I ordered a few supplies and…"
I ordered a few supplies and was happy with what I got for the price. Everything felt fairly priced, and the shipping cost was reasonable too. For everyday supplies, it was a practical purchase and definitely felt like good value overall
0
Reply
LawrenceJacques_43
November 27, 2025
"I ran into an issue and reached out…"
I ran into an issue and reached out to support, but the whole process has been frustrating. They were slow to respond and not very helpful when they finally did. I’ve had to keep following up, repeating myself, and doing extra work on my end just to try to get things moving, and it still isn’t fixed.
0
Reply
Have a question about Painful Pleasures?
Log in to ask your Painful Pleasures question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
